Cocoaland Berhad's share price had gone up from RM1.86 to RM2.93 in one year's time (from 23/8/16-23/8/17) a 58% increase.An excellent result for a company in which business is manufacturing and trading of candies, beverages and other related food stuffs. But what drives the rise in share price of Cocoland?does it comes from the business performance or is it just an effect from current bull market?
“Growth is never by mere chance; it is the result of forces working together.”
Lets look into the company's performance to see whether the rise in share price is justified by the business performance or not. Figure 1 shows the trend in revenue,cost of sales,profit and capex for Cocoaland Bhd from 2010-2017. I decided to take 2010 as the base year because in 2010, Fraser & Neave Holdings Bhd (F&N) becomes the 2nd largest shareholder in cocoland (and still the 2nd largest shareholder as per latest annual report)
We can clearly see that revenue is on an upward trend rising exponentially from for the first 4 years and stagnate for the next 3 year but increase back in 2016.Cost of sale is rising in tandem with revenue for the first 4 years but starts to fall afterwards. This trend can also be seen in profit and capex, figure 2 shows a clearer picture of the relationship between capex, profit and its free cash flow
We know that prior to 2013,Cocoaland Bhd had been spending a lot on capex to expand its production line in rawang thus its free cash flow (FCF) is in the negative territory.But since then we can see that capex drops significantly,profit and FCF start to rise as the company's investment starts to bear its fruit. Similar improvement can be observed with Return on Equity (ROE) and net profit margin (NP)
Cash Conversion Cycle (CCC) is a metric used to gauge the effectiveness of a company's management and, consequently, the overall health of that company. The calculation measures how fast a company can convert cash on hand into inventory and accounts payable, through sales and accounts receivable, and then back into cash (Investopedia) , the lower the days the better.
CCC = DIO + DSO - DPO
Days Inventory Outstanding (DIO) refers to the number of days it takes to sell an entire inventory. A smaller DIO is preferred. Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) refers to the number of days needed to collect on sales, or accounts receivable. A smaller DSO is also preferred. Days Payable Outstanding (DPO) refers to the company's payment of its own bills, or accounts payable. By maximizing this number, the company holds onto cash longer, increasing its investment potential. Thus, a longer DPO is preferred (Investopedia)
I know we are supposed to look at a company's CCC in comparison with its peer but lets look at the trend over the years as shown below.
Cocoaland Bhd's CCC has been increasing from 80 days prior 2013 to 90 days. Is it a bad omen for Cocoaland Bhd? A sign of dark days ahead? Not so fast folks, it is normal for a company to extend credit to their customer especially during its expansion/growth phase, the percentage of impairment of account receivable is very low with an average of 6% for the past 7 years.It shows that the management is very cautious in extending credit term to its customer. The increase in ROE, Net profit and FCF further justify the increase of Cash Conversion Cycle.
|South East Asia||15%|
Back in 2010, Cocoaland's revenue comes only from Malaysia and China but had since then diversify its revenue steam from various region and is planning to penetrate more market in coming years. This shows that the management is hard at work in expanding the business to capture more market overseas,this shows tht cocoaland is a good consumer stock with worldwide presence
Leverage Success Sdn Bhd a company controlled by the company's director which in turns control 38.04% of Cocoaland Berhad and Frazer & Neave Holding Bhd. controls 27.19, this shows that the management holds substantial interest in the company and with F&N as second largest shareholder it will definitely brings strategic synergy to Cocoaland because F&N being in the consumer industry itself will not simply invest its money for the sake of capital appreciation or dividend income.The effect of this synergy can been seen in the development and improvement of Cocoaland's business over the years
From my opinion the appreciation in Cocoaland Bhd's share price is justified by the business performance and furthermore current utilization rate is only at 55% and the company is planning to boost it to 80% in the next 3 years,there is a lot of room for growth which is what we want to see in a growth stock, the ability to generate more revenue.
Beside growth,the company had been paying dividen constantly with an average of 50% payout ratio and average dividend yield of 4% while maintaining clean balance sheet (net cash) and healthy cash flows. This is a hallmark of a good management team.
Action speaks louder than word.Refer back to figure 2 (Profit vs Capex vs FCF) and you will understand the quality of the company. Revenue, profit and FCF is picking up, cost of sales is going down despite high volatility in its raw material price,high CAPEX spending is over and now its time to focus on growing the company forward.
ROE is at 19%,ROIC at 20%,Net profit margin 16%, FCF yield 5%, 30sen cash per share (net cash position) Cocoaland Bhd is on its way toward a steady and consistent growth. Cocoland is suitable for investor with a long term horizon (more than 1 year) not for those who seek instant gratification on their stock picks.
Disclaimer : This article is only for sharing purpose but any feedback is most welcome
For further reading i strongly suggest looking at Donkey Stock earlier post
And recent news for Cocoaland Berhad: